Day 309

Posted by Erin Bowling on

Today's Reading:

Matthew 26:36-75
Mark 14:32-72
Luke 22:39-71
John 18:1-27

Peter stood near the fire in the courtyard warming his hands against the cold night. He had just climbed up the Kidron Valley from the Mount of Olives on the other side, in the middle of the night, following the guards who had arrested Jesus. From the courtyard Peter could see the outline of the olive trees across the valley in the garden of Gethsemane. He was waiting, listening for any word about Jesus’ arrest and what would happen next. Something quieter and heavier kept pressing on him: it was the promise he had made only hours before in the Upper Room, when he swore that he would not fail or fall away, that he was ready to die with Jesus if it came to that.

He would have been thinking about the warning Jesus gave him about the rooster and the denials. The young servant girl startled Peter. When she first spoke, her question was simple, and he answered too fast and denied knowing Jesus. The second time, he was more defensive and gruff, as if he needed to convince both them and himself. By the third time Peter was asked if he was a follower of Jesus, his accent as a Galilean gave him away, and the denial came out rough and desperate. He cursed and swore that he did not know the man.  

Then the rooster crowed. The sound cut through the night air like a punch to the gut. In an instant, the guilt would have settled in his heart. The other disciples had already fled. Peter turned; the weight of his words stayed with him, and once alone he bawled, a hard, gut-wrenching cry, knowing the promises he made to the Lord were broken. The cost of his denial could be felt in his soul.  

How do you usually respond when the weight of your own failure settles in? Especially when the compromise started small and then grew under pressure.


Jesus and His disciples had just finished celebrating Passover in the upper room
, and He warned them they would all fall away. They headed out of the city and over to the Mount of Olives to the Garden of Gethsemane. The garden was full of huge olive trees and walking paths that Jesus often used. It was a quiet place to retreat, especially for prayer. Knowing what the night held, Jesus wanted time to Himself for prayer. He left most of the disciples near the entrance and took His closest disciples, Peter, James, and John, with Him farther into the garden. He was distraught and told them His soul was overwhelmed with sorrow to the point of death and asked the three of them to stay awake and keep watch while He went a bit farther into the garden. You can feel the crushing weight of His words. Jesus honestly prayed and asked Abba, the Father, at three different times, if the cup of suffering and death could be taken from Him. Jesus was fully human with feelings, dread, and pain. But He knew it was the Father’s will, and He chose to be obedient. As the night moved on, He went to see the three who He caught sleeping. They were exhausted; it was late, and they had a full day of Passover, dinner, and the climb to Gethsemane. They wanted to be supportive of Him, but their own human needs won out. In Luke, an angel appeared and strengthened Jesus, and under extreme stress He prayed harder as He was sweating drops of blood that fell to the ground. The sweat mixed with blood showed the intensity of His inner struggle, and the Father provided help. Just as we are given strength through the truth of the Word. As a human, Jesus needed the Father, and yet still submitted to the Father’s will. There is a real medical condition called hematidrosis, where extreme stress can cause the capillaries near the sweat glands to rupture so blood mixes with the sweat. The cost of the cross could already be felt.

Judas showed up in the garden, as he would have known this was a frequent place for Jesus to retreat to meet with His disciples for prayer and quiet reflection (John 18:2). Judas led the chief priests and officials, followed by the armed crowd, to the exact location of Jesus and signaled it was Him with a kiss of greeting. This is the hour that Jesus had known was coming. Jesus, being omniscient, knew exactly why Judas was there (Matthew 26:50). Jesus called him “friend”; the word in Greek was not for a close friend, but more an acquaintance, companion, or mate. He acknowledged their former friendship but at a distance, without being bitter or sarcastic.

Upon arresting Jesus, the accounts in Matthew and Mark said one of Jesus’ companions cut off the ear of the servant of the high priest, Malchus. But in John 18:10, it was noted the companion was in fact Simon Peter, who cut off the right ear, and that Jesus immediately healed it. Being that John was an eyewitness, he could point the finger at Peter. He also wrote his Gospel much later, and there would be fewer Roman repercussions for naming the person. The reason Jesus healed the servant’s ear was so that there would be no evidence that it even happened, saving Peter from any repercussions.  

As predicted, the disciples fled. In Mark, there was a humorous sentence about a man in a linen cloth, a night garment or burial shroud. When Jesus was seized, the man fled, naked, leaving his garment behind. This could have been John Mark, the writer of the Gospel himself. He probably had gotten dressed in the outer garment in a rush because of the commotion, and it was the middle of the night. The panic and fleeing showed just how much Jesus was abandoned.

In John, Scripture notes that Jesus was taken to Annas for questioning first; he was the father-in-law to the high priest Caiaphas. Peter followed from the garden down the Kidron Valley and across the old red bridge, then up the mountain to Caiaphas’ palace. Part of the old walking path/road has been unearthed and is still visible today right by the courtyard location. This is where Peter would have waited outside to hear the outcome of Jesus’ arrest. The chief priests and the entire Sanhedrin (similar to the USA Supreme Court) were called together in the middle of the night for this “trial,” although they found no evidence against Him. Finally, two came forward who misrepresented Jesus’ words about dying on the cross and rising in three days, but they claimed Jesus said He would destroy God’s Temple and rebuild it in three days. This showed the injustice and the falseness of the trial. The high priest asked Jesus if He was the Messiah, the Son of God, which became the charges for blasphemy. The leaders and guards tore their clothes, spit on Him, and hit Him.

Through the night, the four Gospels had a different focus on the same story. Matthew’s focus was how Jesus was willing to submit. Mark gave a vivid picture of the failure of Peter. Luke focused on the powerful darkness, with the angel and bloody sweat showing the anguish of Jesus submitting to the Father’s will. John’s account was controlled, with the injustice of the trial.

Today's Discussion question:

How do you usually respond when the weight of your own failure settles in? Especially when the compromise started small and then grew under pressure?

Click here to link to our Facebook group for discussion, questions, and additional content.